![]()
MY BOOK ![]() ARTICLES Peak Freaks Hurricane NYC From Grief to Action (pdf) The Coming Energy Crunch Auto Asphyxiation Alarmingly Useless LINKS Kunstler Oil Drum NYC NoLandGrab.org Starts & Fits Dope on the Slope Brooklyn Views Polis Atlantic Yards Report Transportation Alternatives Rushkoff Planetizen Global Public Media Laid Off Dad Bird to the North Auto-Free NY Gothamist Gotham Gazette Mom Previous Life Winds READING Catastrophe Notes Small Urban Spaces High Tide Powerdown Rendezvous With Rama Ancient Sunlight Geography of Nowhere The Power Broker Resource Wars Invisible Heroes Nothing Sacred ARCHIVES June 2003 July 2003 August 2003 November 2003 December 2003 January 2004 February 2004 March 2004 April 2004 May 2004 June 2004 July 2004 August 2004 October 2004 November 2004 December 2004 January 2005 February 2005 March 2005 April 2005 May 2005 June 2005 July 2005 August 2005 September 2005 October 2005 November 2005 December 2005 January 2006 February 2006 March 2006 April 2006 May 2006 June 2006 January 2010
|
![]()
Step 1: Admit you have a problem that's out of control The New York Times has been running some unusually demented automobile propaganda pieces lately. The extremity and ridiculousness of these stories is a clear sign of desperation. As more and more Americans wake up to the feeling that our car-centered way of life is dysfunctional, destructive, and out of control, our culture is going into overdrive to convince us otherwise. Sitting in hours of traffic, going broke at the gas pump, watching acres of greenspace turn into asphalt, Wal-Marts and muffler shops, Americans can see with their own eyes and feel in their own hearts that something is wrong. Something is broken. Even if we can't yet imagine another way it could be, we know that the way things are is not working for us anymore. In service to our cars we are making ourselves fat and unhappy, destroying our sense of community, turning the planet into a gigantic greenhouse, declaring a never-ending war for the energy resources necessary to keep the whole system rolling along. Even the most willfully blind among us must see that the promises of freedom, fun, power and speed made in all of those car ads just aren't paying out. These Times stories, like the increasingly absurd ads that run adjacent to them, are so far out of touch with reality they remind me of the behavior of a late-stage alcoholic. We'll lie, steal, invade a country -- we'll say and do anything to keep feeding our addiction, pretend it's OK, and plow ahead with the very activity that is making ourselves, our society and our planet so very sick. Like the serious addict, we are a culture in denial. In his lengthy argument for more cars, more highways, and lots of expensive new technology to make them run better, John Tierney, begins to take that important first step towards breaking the addiction and beginning the recovery process. Implicit in his Autonomist Manifesto is the admission that we have a problem. Unfortunately, the "autonomists" don't take the full first step towards recovery in that they don't recognize that the problem is totally out of their control, that they are powerless to manage the problem by their typical methods, and that they need some radical form of intervention to set things straight and get healthy again. Tierney goes to great length to convince us (and himself, it seems) that expensive new whizbang technologies will enable us to expand our sprawled out, car-dependent, energy-guzzling lifestyle indefinitely. Just as an alcoholic tries to convince himself he has control over his problem by counting beers or switching to a different drink, Tierney's so-called "autonomists" believe they can get a handle on America's car-sprawl problem by putting magnets in the highways or switching to hydrogen. Like the blinded addict, they don't recognize that this is only feeding the addiction. More resources and technology for more highways and more cars is and has been the problem for a good 60 years now. It's not the solution. There were so many problems with Tierney's "manifesto." The biggest ones for me were these: How can you purport to an intelligent discussion of the costs and benefits of the automobile without even mentioning the fact that 45,000 Americans are killed by motor vehicles each year? How do you just completely omit this annual Vietnam War's worth of casualties? How can the word "oil" not appear once in your essay, never mind any discussion of the fact that it is becoming catastrophically difficult to discover, secure and produce the vast, steady supply of cheap oil necessary to "keep America rolling." How do you fail to discuss any of the environmental, social and aesthetic impacts of a car-oriented life? And most of all, how do you figure that the 99.9% of the world's human beings who do not transport themselves in $45,000, 7 mpg tinted-window Chevy Avalanches are, in fact, "the elite?" Make no mistake: The alpha-elite of our planet today is the American motorist consumer. He may wear jeans, shop at Wal-Mart, and watch Nascar on TV, but he is the planet's top dog. He has the biggest ecological footprint. He uses the most resources. He has serfs the world over working overtime to satisfy his every need and desire. Though Tierney's solutions will only create more problems, at least he takes the first half-step towards recovery by acknowledging that we have a problem. The Times' October 8 piece, "My Life, My Crossfire Roadster," didn't get that far. This amazing little article instead reflects a culture revelling fully in its illness and dependency, like frat boys sucking on a beer bong before passing out and defecating all over themselves. If there is a Pulitzer Prize for "Most Shameless Advertorial in a Major American Journalistic Organ" this story should win it. The piece profiles Donna Christensen, a 35-year-old "advertising saleswoman in Detroit." (Hmmm... I wonder who she works for?) Here's some of what Donna has to say to the Times (interspersed with my commentary): I've always been a carefree, drive-with-the-top-down sort of person, I just didn't have the vehicle to express it... Yes, I know how you feel, Donna. I too must have a vehicle on-hand to fully express myself. It's like, people don't really know how sad I am about the state of the world until they see me drive by in my Buick Le Sabre. When they see me in the Le Sabre, they immediately know what I'm all about. I have two dogs and I love to garden — a real S.U.V. lifestyle — so I needed something with lots of room.... Totally! It's impossible to garden or take care of dogs without an S.U.V. I never loved to drive; my needs were strictly practical... Right. The gardening. The dogs. But joy is the least practical of emotions, and while my Crossfire may not be roomy, it sure is a blast to drive.... I know you're feeling it during the AM rush, Donna. Commuting by bike, I often pass long lines of vehicles stuck in traffic. The faces behind the windshields often appear grim and angry. Most motorists don't seem to be having a blast like you, Donna. What up? Would they be happier and more joyful if they were sitting immobilized in traffic behind the wheel of a yellow Crossfire Roadster? I didn't mean to get it... So, you also make accidental $30,000 purchases? Man, I'm glad I'm not the only one. The lease on my Jeep was up, so I went to my local Chrysler dealer to trade it in for something new. Then I spotted a beautiful roadster sitting in the middle of the showroom floor. It was a yellow, the color of a banana or lemon chiffon. From a styling standpoint, it was futuristic yet retro, with a sloping back and a long, elegant hood that gives it an almost delicate look. From the back the car looked sporty, but not tough looking or macho. This was a roadster a woman could love... When you find the roadster you love, don't let go, Donna. Don't let go. I asked the salesman to move the other cars out of the way so I could take it for a spin. I'd never driven anything like it. The car was quick, powerful and nimble, a cheetah with wheels. It was a beautiful day. My hair was whipping in the wind, and every worry I had seemed to fly away. I felt completely free... Watch out Prozac. You've got competition. And the name is Crossfire! My goal was to talk myself out of buying it, but I couldn't come up with one compelling reason not to. I went back on Monday and drove it home on a three-year lease. It didn't have any fancy amenities like XM radio or a navigational system, but I didn't care. They had this one; I loved it, so I got it... And Donna, let me tell you: The automobile dealers of America appreciate your work in helping to normalize this sort of irrational and irresponsible consumer behavior. We really depend on that. It makes our jobs much easier. Thank you. I soon discovered that top-down driving changes things. One's attitudes toward grooming, for instance... Totally. I stopped showering after I got my new car. The first time I drove to the hairdresser, she took one look at the car and said, "I have to give you convertible hair." And she lopped about five inches off. I get up in the morning, I spray my hair into place, and I don't care what happens to it. Wow, Donna, it sounds like this automobile really changed your life... If I have to choose between keeping my hair neat and loving the driving experience, I'll take the driving experience... Yo, I hear that, Donna. Heck, I'd shave my head into a Mister T mohawk if it could get me through the Holland Tunnel on a Sunday night in less than 45 minutes. I also bought new sunglasses — big ones, like windshields for my eyes. I feel like a different person...
Indeed! Delaying THE INEVITABLE is good policy. Donna, you just keep driving, baby. Scientists say that all that motoring is making the planet warmer. And that means more top-down days for everyone!
Comments
That is so excellent, Aaron!
It's a real scandal that most major newspapers have sections for car "reporting" in addition to the special advertising sections. Our local newspaper monopoly calls its section "Motoring" as if driving a car is a quaint passtime out of the 1890's. A different standard of journalist ethics exists for the "reporters" who write for these sections. The reporter for "Motoring" for instance, also appeared on television in an auto windshield commercial and does the daily traffic report on a local TV news show. The major media will never be critical of cars as long as they reap billions from car advertising. The same situation existed before cigarette advertising was removed from television. Advertising buys influence. Anonymous Avidor
Donna in Detroit may not be stuck in traffic like the people you see every morning. I hear that freeway construction has sliced up Detroit so completely and made it so pedestrian unfriendly that there is no traffic congestion in the city proper -- because so few people want to go there.
Thanks for the great blog. Post a Comment (You'll be taken to Blogger's site and then returned back to this page.) |